Reply To: i can only make one choice…..

[deWiTTERS]

Make sure you place 4 spaces before every line inside the “in case”

thief gives choices for "So give me that ring, or die!"
in case "Sure"
    hero says "Here is the ring."
in case "Never!"
    thief says "Then I'll fight you for it!"

So the “in case”s must be on the same level, and the others 4 spaces deeper.

I hope this is the problem you are facing.